Title:
|
The Spirit of Athens : the reception of fifth-century BC Athenian history in eighteenth-century British political thought
|
This thesis seeks to explore the important and numerous ways in
which British political commentators engaged with fifth-century Be
Athenian history, with particular reference to the rise and fall of
Athenian sea power and maritime empire, in the eighteenth
century. It argues that Athens provided British commentators with
historical material in debates over the nature of maritime empire,
the rights of colonists, the influence of luxury on imperial powers,
the role of the individual in a free constitution, the causes of war,
and the spread of factionalism and violence. This material was, at
the same time, interpreted in the light of political concerns, while
helping to shape the nature of various contemporary debates.
The idea that the rise, decline, and fall of the fifth-century Athenian
Empire and democracy was common intellectual currency and seen
as politically useful is contentious. Edward Andrew argued that
'Athens definitely was not a model' for eighteenth-century thinkers,
while J . T. Roberts sees Athens as an anti-democratic model. That
is to sayan example of a constitution to be avoided. My thesis will
add nuance to these accounts by considering the reception of
various facets of Athenian history in total rather than individually.
Over the coming chapters we will see how it is misleading to
separate the history of the empire, the role of luxury, debates over
Pericles, and the causes and violence of the Peloponnesian War. All
these different strands together form a compelling case, I argue, for
the importance of Athens in eighteenth-century British thought.
This thesis will further point to the influence of readings of
Thucydides, Plutarch, Herodotus, Xenophon, Aristotle, and others
on the reception of Athenian history. The classical texts provided
the raw material from which ideas of Athenian history were formed.
This thesis will point to various traditions of reading these texts that
were current in the eighteenth century, which provided material in
contemporary political debates. Furthermore, I will explore ways in
which readings of these texts problematised received wisdom. For
example,. around the time of the American Revolution, Thucydides'
depiction of the descent of the Athenian Empire into tyranny
provided troubling material when compared with the perceived
liberty of the British Empire.
|