Title:
|
Virtue, enmity and the art of tormenting : resistance to sensibility in women's writing, 1740-1800
|
This study aims to locate, examine and account for the many, and varied, forms of resistance to
sentimental culture advanced by eighteenth-century women writers. Through reference to essays,
novels, poems and memoirs, the thesis traces the evolution of this opposition over a sixty-year
period. It contends that the subtly subversive representations of unsentimental conduct depicted by
women writers at mid-century anticipate and shape the more explicitly antisentimental rhetoric
espoused by more openly radical figures in later decades. The thesis aims to unite these two
elements by tracing the evolution of this critique from its earliest beginnings - embedded, opaquely,
in the literature of the 1740s - to its free expression in the' transparently antisentimental writings of
the 1790s and beyond.
The first chapter argues that Jane Collier's 1753 work An Essay on the Art of Ingeniously Tormenting
anticipates the antisentimental themes discussed in Mary Wollstonecraft's Vindication of the Rights
of Woman (1792). The second chapter examines six novels published by Collier's close friend and
collaborator, Sarah Fielding, between 1744 and 1760. It argues that Fielding played an important
role in the inception of an unsentimental tradition in eighteenth-century fiction. The third chapter
addresses the considerable body of poetry written by women on the theme of indifference. It
contends that indifference functioned as a further thematic site upon which the gendered
prescriptions of sentimental culture could be contested. The fourth chapter examines a range of
memoirs written by socially transgressive women which exploit, subvert and contest sentimental
values. The final chapter discusses the development of the antisentimental novel in the 1780s and
1790s and considers the extent to which it can be read as distinct from earlier critiques of
sentimental culture.
|