Title:
|
The management of recurrent pleural effusions : exploring pleurodesis and indwelling pleural catheter studies
|
Introduction
Pleural effusions are often a source of significant morbidity for patients. Management of recurrent
pleural effusions, especially those caused by cancer, can be challenging. There is an increasing
recognition that higher-quality studies, including randomised controlled trials (RCT) are needed
to address many areas of pleural practice.
Methods
The initial portion of this thesis describes the design, set-up and recruitment of two important
RCTs in malignant effusions: TAPPS, which compares talc poudrage at medical thoracoscopy with
traditional talc slurry; and IPC-PLUS, in which patients treated with an indwelling pleural catheter
(IPC) are randomised to receive either placebo or talc slurry as outpatients.
Using the experiences of these two studies as examples, there then follows an exploration of the
challenges to delivering large-scale malignant pleural studies, with a particular focus on
practitioners' attitudes.
The final parts of this thesis describe two additional novel uses for IPCs. Firstly, their use and utility
in non-malignant disease is explored through the largest published series in this area. Secondly,
there follows a description of the design, set-up and preliminary results of the SEAL-M PE trial, a
first-in-human study examining the safety profile of a unique silver-nitrate eluting pleural
catheter.
Discussion
The results of the TAPPS and IPC-P LUS trials have the potential to significantly alter how recu rrent
malignant pleural effusions are managed in the future. The attitudes of pleural practitioners in
the UK would suggest a desire for better standards of evidence and a willingness to explore new
areas. However, the delivery of high quality studies may be impaired by the realities of clinical
practice. Patients with non-malignant effusions are a heterogeneous group, with further study of
IPCs in this area needed. Preliminary results from the SEAL-M PE trial would suggest that the
catheter can be used safely in humans, albeit with a higher chance of adverse events.
|