Title:
|
The dynamics of consumption, resource use and waste : systems approaches to resource efficiency
|
Resource efficiency (RE) is a characteristics of the way resources such as energy and materials
are used within everyday activities and it is a critical concern for those working in the fields of
climate change mitigation and environmental protection. Resource efficiency affects the rates at
which resources are extracted from sources and waste streams such as greenhouse gas
emissions and material wastes are generated. This thesis presents six studies in which methods
from the fields of management, engineering, and systems thinking were used to evaluate and
expand upon existing waste prevention and carbon management methods - two of the real-world
approaches being used to improve RE. Insights from these studies were combined to examine RE
from several theoretical angles - as a problem of socio-technical transition, as a wicked problem,
as a problem full of conundrums, as a problem that can be addressed using systems thinking
methods, and as a problem for which an underlying vision has not yet been well articulated and
accepted.
Key contributions to knowledge from the six studies include: Insights from the trial of a holistic
carbon management method for buildings that includes consideration of the interactions between
end-use technologies, stakeholder groups, organisational structure, and buildings. The application
of critical systems heuristics theory to investigate issues related to competing goals within planning
for the low-carbon redevelopment of an urban enterprise zone. A waste prevention model for the
UK economy, developed using system dynamics, which produced insights into waste prevention
pathways and findings about the usefulness to government of the systems methods used. The
development of a theory linking social, economic, technological, and infrastructure factors as an
proposed explanation of the causes of Jevons' Paradox; a model of road transport carbon
emissions as an application of the theory; and the testing of a suite of four types of interventions
that could reduce greenhouse gas emissions enough to meet EU goals by 2030.
Key contributions to knowledge from a synthesis of the study findings include: Analysis of RE as a
wicked problem, through applying the ten characteristics of wickedness, and implications of this
wickedness for RE practice. Analysis of RE as a problem of socio-technical transition, through
developing a Causal Stratified Sustainability version of the Multi Level Perspective which portrays
the relationship between the natural environment, science, and the economy at different stages of
maturity. A proposition for a preanalytic vision for the field of RE, with the intended purpose of
moving the field of RE away from its mostly pragmatic stance and developing a theoretical
grounding from which to improve RE practice in future. A framework of applicability of systems
models and methods to RE. Reflections on the use of PS Ms within the field of RE. Personal
reflections on the impact of systems methods on my own understanding, and the dualistic role of
engineers with regard to RE.
|