Title:
|
An interpretive case study of distributed leadership in a Welsh primary school
|
Title - An Interpretive Case Study of Distributed Leadership in a Welsh Primary
School
Background - This paper explores the model of distributed leadership operating
within a Welsh primary school from the perspective of a selection of staff working in the school. The school was chosen because the head teacher had stated that the
school operated a model of distributed leadership, a model which is advocated in the
Welsh School Effectiveness Framework (NAW, 2008).
In order to investigate "How is leadership distributed at Fox Primary School", the
research design of this dissertation explores the distribution of leadership throughout
the environment and people of the organisation. To address the overarching
research question two specific research sub-questions are addressed in this
dissertation. These are:
1. Who performs leadership roles at Fox Primary School?
2. How is leadership coordinated and aligned at Fox Primary School?
Methods - Data collection took place in three phases. Phase one consisted of the
collection of internal documents, including school improvement plans and staffing
structures, and external reports by Investors in People and Estyn in order to gather a
environmental context in which the staff who work in the school operate. Phase two
consisted of individual semi-structured interviews with the head teacher, deputy head
teacher, school business manager and a teaching assistant. Phase three consisted
of a focus group interview with three class teachers, the school business manager
and a teaching assistant. The interview and focus group data, which were gathered
to explore the perceptions of leadership operation in the school, were analysed using
Nvivo 9 software.
Conclusions - The research concluded that, based on the perceptions of a sample
of staff from within Fox Primary School, the practice of distributed leadership is less
than expected, given the head teacher's initial statement that the school operated a
model of distributed leadership, and that its implementation is constrained by the
requirement that the school meet externally imposed aims relating to pupil outcomes
in literacy and numeracy. This conclusion is based on key findings which indicate
that the focus of leadership activity is influenced by Government; that the role of the
head teacher remains significant even through leadership is distributed; that
opportunities for enactment of distributed leadership between governors and staff is
limited; and that staff vary in their perceptions of the value and opportunity for
informal leadership by parents. However, it was found that the alignment and
coordination of leadership is supported through a combination of traditional
hierarchical structures and novel flattened structures for curriculum development.
The curriculum development structures and the school's school improvement
planning processes support the distribution of leadership throughout the school
community, although the foci of the school improvement plan are significantly
influenced by Government.
|