Title:
|
General population screening for sudden cardiac death in young individuals : the UK experience
|
BACKGROUND: Sudden cardiac death (SCD) in any young person is a tragic event with a
significant number of life-years lost. Previous data from Italy suggest that pre-participation
screening using an electrocardiogram (ECG) reduces the incidence of SCD in competitive
athletes. However, the majority of SCD occurs in non-athletes within the general population.
In the United Kingdom, state sponsored screening for cardiac disorders is confined to
symptomatic individuals or those with a family history of inherited cardiac conditions or
premature cardiac death.
AIMS: To assess the feasibility and efficacy of screening, incorporating an ECG and point-ofcare
echocardiography, in young individuals from the general population for cardiovascular
conditions associated with SCD.
METHODS: Between 2008-2012, 10,359 young individuals aged 14-35 years underwent
screening by an attending cardiologist comprising a health questionnaire, physical
examination and ECG. ECGs were analysed in accordance with the European Society of
Cardiology (ESC} recommendations for ECG interpretation in athletes for Group-1 (trainingrelated)
and Group-2 (potentially pathological) patterns. Group-2 ECG patterns warrant
further cardiac evaluation. Individuals with findings raising suspicion of cardiomyopathy
underwent on-site echocardiography. Individuals with abnormalities from the screening
episode were referred for further evaluation for conditions associated with SCD and
followed up annually to assess outcomes. Based on these data comparisons of the efficacy
of different screening strategies were made and costs and cost effectiveness were
calculated.
RESULTS: Symptoms of a cardiovascular nature were reported in 44.2% of individuals, a
family history of SCD or condition associated with SCD was reported in 3.8% and an
abnormal physical examination occurred in 0.3% of individuals. ECG patterns suggestive of
cardiac pathology were identified in 22.4% of individuals, predominantly due to
abnormalities of QTc measurement. Male gender and black ethnicity demonstrated the
strongest association with ESC Group-2 ECG patterns. Point-of-care echocardiography for
individuals with suspicion of cardiomyopathy significantly reduced the number of patients
requiring further evaluation as only 14.8% of these individuals demonstrated abnormal
echocardiographic findings. Positive diagnosis of a cardiovascular condition associated with
SCD was identified in 0.3% of individual;; (cardiomyopathy, n=6; primary electrical disease,
n=17; Marfan syndrome, n=4). This screening strategy demonstrated a sensitivity of 100%,
specificity of 93.2% and false-positive rate of 6.8% with an estimated cost of £106,141 per
diagnosis made.
CONCLUSIONS: Screening for conditions associated with SCD in the general population is
feasible. A screening strategy incorporating the ECG and point-of-care echocardiography is
associated with a high sensitivity and specificity and low false-positive rate as well as
favourable cost analyses.
|