Title:
|
The 'having, doing and being' of fishing well : assessing the social wellbeing of Northern Ireland's fishing households in a changing coastal environment
|
There is growing interest in how the concept of wellbeing might be applied to
fisheries, especially in terms of deepening assessment of the ways in which decline in
the fisheries sector is affecting fishing-dependent families, and the wider community
(Coulthard et al. 2011). This study applies a three-dimensional wellbeing framework
and methodology, adapted from the ESRC research group on Wellbeing in Developing
Countries (WeD) University of Bath, to gain insight into the wellbeing of fishing
households in Northern Ireland, in particular the impacts of changing access to fish on
wellbeing. The three-dimensional approach considers material, relational and
subjective dimensions and the study illustrates the importance of all three
dimensions for a full assessment of wellbeing (McGregor 2007, McGregor and
Sumner 2010). In light of EU policy change and fisheries decline, the central aims of
this thesis are to explore how changing access to fisheries affects the wellbeing of
fishers and their families and the coping strategies fishing households and individuals
use in response to this change.
This thesis presents empirical data on wellbeing from a person-centred
perspective. That is, how men and women in fishing communities define their
wellbeing and what they value most for a good life. The study presents findings on
the resources fishing households have access to and the relationships that influence
fishing behaviour. The findings emphasise the importance of embedding our
understanding of wellbeing within the enabling environment - the social structures
and relational processes that can enable or constrain how people are able to achieve
wellbeing. This thesis shows that the there are multiple factors driving change in NI
fishing society, in particular the reform of the EU's Common Fisheries Policy, the
growing environmental discourse within fisheries management and the economic
recession. The study highlights the connection between fisheries and the wider social
and economic health of the region and the importance of understanding the local
context. Despite the close proximity of the fishing communities in this study, the
findings show local variations and heterogeneity between communities and even
within, which supports the argument for scalable solutions to fisheries management
issues.
This thesis highlights the important wellbeing functions of a fishing way of life
as well as the increasing demand to adapt to change and the consequences of
adaptation and coping strategies for wellbeing. The outcomes of changing access to
fish for wellbeing are multi-dimensional and include economic insecurity, health and
safety issues, changing relationships (at household, community and State level), in
particular, frustration with the current governance system as a result of a lack of
voice in decision-making processes. The thesis concludes with key policy
recommendations, sign-posting a pathway to wellbeing and sustainable fisheries
governance.
|