Title:
|
Reflections of the 'Other': foreign polities in archaic and classical greek political discourse
|
Throughout their history interactions with foreigners had a profound influence on the
Greek sense of' self and the development of a Panhellenic identity. In many ways,
Greek culture developed out of interactions with ' others'. However, Greek ethnicity
did not operate as a polarity with strictly defmed categories but was a sliding scale.
The endpoints were strongly structuralist understandings of 'Greek' and 'Barbarian',
with various intermediary points to accommodate those who did not conform to these
precise categories. Greek ethnicity was complex and fluid, meaning different things at
different times to different people.
The texts examined in this study, Homer's epic poems, Herodotus' Histories, and
Ctesias' Persica, all variously display what it meant to be Greek, 'other', and the
shades and subtleties inherent in such concepts. Homer's Trojans, although
traditionally considered to be similar to the Greeks, exhibit several characteristics of
'others' as typified in fifth-century concepts of the Barbarian, demonstrating that such
stereotypes have long roots. Although several contemporary texts emphasise the
differences between Greeks and Barbarians, Herodotus provides an extremely
sophisticated portrait of ' others' by refraining from relying upon simple stereotypes.
While Homer and Herodotus present the shades and subtleties inherent in conceptions
of ethnicity and alterity, Ctesias' work functions on the premise of polarity between
Greeks and ' others'. Ctesias imagines Persia as a fantastical 'other', the opposite of
Greece in almost every way. He plays to the stereotypes, revealing the complexities
inherent in notions of ' self and 'other' .
This project demonstrates that it is possible to understand contemporary Greek
political thought through a backwards reading of Greek texts about 'others' . The
authors examined respond to contemporary political concerns, particularly discussions
of wealth, access to power, and decision making, in various ways, providing unique
insight into the contemporary political thought that influenced each of these authors.
|