Title:
|
"It's finding that balance" : families negotiating the discourses of youth and technology
|
The past decade has seen an increase in domestic ownership of ICTs, access to the
internet, the growing popularity of video gaming, and also the development of social media,
and social networking sites such as Facebook. Alongside this, Government has promoted
domestic ownership for beneficial purposes in education, citizenship, improved
communication and access to social services. During this period two contradictory
discourses have emerged which position young people and their families in relation to new
technologies. The first sees children and young people as being in particular need of
gaining ICT skills and of passing these skills on to parents who have been deemed less
able. In contrast to this, a negative discourse of moral panic about new technologies and
youth has been highly visible in the media. Parents and children are required to negotiate
these conflicting discourses in their everyday lives and the aim of this thesis is to examine
family practices with ICTs and new technologies in the face of powerful official and popular
discourses around youth and technology.
The research presented in this thesis draws upon social practice theory, specifically, literacy
as social practice and Morgan's (1996) approach to family practices which identifies
domains of family life as labour, care, gender, consumption and the body. The research has
two strands; the first is a discourse analysis of media texts which seeks to highlight current
popular discourses and how children and youth are discursively constructed within media in
relation to new technologies. The second strand is an ethnographically informed fieldwork
study of four local families. This part of the study employs novel collaborative research
projects which encouraged the families to produce their own data. Interview and focus
groups with family members were also used.
The findings suggest a high level of moral panic in popular discourses around youth and
technology with an overall negative portrayal of young people. Discourses of youth as risky
or as being at risk polarise the discussion and stifle alternative or competing narratives. A
particularly strong and popular construction of childhood as a period of innocence and purity
is present. Within this construction closeness to nature, healthy bodies and sexual
innocence are emphasised and technology is seen as a disruptive and polluting force, which
is at odds with the celebratory and beneficial discourse promoted by government.
The findings show that all four families were engaged in a balancing process between what
they felt were beneficial aspects of new technologies and those they felt were risky and
harmful. Family practices with ICTs were often shaped by parents' beliefs about childhood
and the sort of childhood they wanted their children to experience. Parents drew upon a
dominant Western model of childhood which was prevalent in media texts, and this was
often the driving force behind parents' rules and regulations in relation to ICT. Initially,
parents espoused the official celebratory discourses of ICT as beneficial to their children 's
education; however, the research methods allowed for a more nuanced understanding to be
developed which probed their initial viewpoint and demonstrated that parents were sceptical
of the benefits of ICT for their children'S education and literacy practices. Their children's
eventual future success as adults was the over-riding concern of parents and ICTs occupied
an ambivalent role in this process.
The findings suggest that the term 'digital divide' is unhelpful in understanding practices with
ICTs. Children and adults alike often have a long history of exposure to a range of ICTs,
with competency and expertise developing in ad hoc ways at different levels and associated
with different social practices, frequently based on real world interests, hobbies and family
practices. The researcher suggests research that investigates an individual's digital profi le
and digital exposure over time would be a more helpful approach, in particular in examining
gendered practices with ICTs in the family.
|