Title:
|
An investigation into the interaction between cognitive processing and learning with specific
reference to the potential beneficial effects of Kodaly based music instruction
|
This thesis explores the Kodaly approach to music education. The study was motivated by an
interest in exploring what is meant by the Kodaly philosophy of music education in the 21st
century and whether it is a good approach for adopting in the school curriculum.
The researcher's professional interests and expertise led her to investigate how the Kodaly
philosophy of music education has been adapted from its roots in Hungary in the twentieth
century to present day Hungary and by music teachers in the UK working in a variety of
teaching settings. Questionnaires and case studies were used to explore these issues. The
thesis also investigated whether a Kodaly approach to music education is an enjoyable one.
Issues of motivation and attitudes to music lessons were explored in a case study carried out
in Hungary and interviews with present and past pupils in a boys' school in the UK. Finally
the thesis explored whether claims made for possible transfer effects of Kodaly training to
other cognitive abilities could be substantiated.
Results showed that Kodaly's philosophy was adhered to in a comprehensive way, but with
some modifications in present day Hungary. His approach was still highly valued by the
Hungarian trained music teachers. In the UK it was found that KodaJy teachers did not have
the same music specialist background as in Hungary and the amount of time devoted to music
teaching in Primary schools was much less. Responses from UK teachers about their
approach led to a suggestion that it is more appropriate for teachers to say they take a Kodaly-based
approach since there was considerable deviation from the programmes proposed
originally by Kodaly.
The results of the longitudinal study showed that length in Kodaly-based music classes did
not result in any significant benefits to other areas of learning. However, a Kodaly approach
to music instruction had benefits to acquisition of musical skills per se. Results also showed
that pupils were highly motivated during Kodaly music classes and that they demonstrated
positive attitudes to their music lessons.
|