Title:
|
The effectiveness of and students' attitude toward
learning English vocabulary through group work versus
individual work in a Taiwanese university
|
This research investigated the effectiveness of group work (GW) in EFL vocabulary
learning by second . year, non-English major, university students in Taiwan, in
comparison with working individually (IW). It also sought to find out students'
attitudes towards vocabulary learning in each mode. The context was
vocabulary-focused tasks following reading comprehension.
In order to gather in-depth information about the process of, vocabulary discovery
and retention and students' attitude to learning vocabulary through these two modes,
questionnaires (44 students) and interviews (24 students) were used, along with
vocabulary knowledge tests to measure knowledge gains (44 students). The design
was repeated measures.
Findings showed that students' overall improvement in vocabulary knowledge with
GW was higher than that with IW. The results inferred from participants' statements
in interviews and choices on the questionnaires showed that students' discovery of
word knowledge in GW was greater than that in IW mainly because of having more
opportunities to give and receive word knowledge from group members. Their
retention of word knowledge in GW was a little higher than in IW because of giving
and receiving helps during group discussion and learning in a friendly environment.
Moreover, working with different group members in each GW. activity . seemed to
affect their construction of groups (e.g. communicating about the tasks, assigning
roles). Finally, students' attitude towards learning vocabulary through GW and IW
changed. They favoured learning vocabulary through GW rather than IW less after
GW was implemented, even though their vocabulary learning was improved.
Pedagogical implications drawn from our findings were twofold for the educational
authorities, English department, and teachers in Taiwan. First, the use of group work
needed be encouraged in English class in secondary school and university. Second,
provision of a vocabulary learning course at university and emphasis vocabulary
learning in the university reading class were needed.
|