Title:
|
The socio-legal identity of organised crime policing
in England and in Italy
|
The fight against organised crime is today a very fertile ground for policy
making at various levels. On one side, manifestations of organised crime have
historically shaped social and institutional perceptions of local and national
threats, while on the other side - because of the perceived transnationality of the
phenomenon - national states have been inclined to develop harmonised and
coordinated responses, struggling towards agreed definitions of organised crime.
This research is a socio-legal comparative · investigation carried out in
England and in Italy through thematic analysis of in-depth interviews and
official documents, wishing to compare the evolution of two national policing
models against organised crime. For the purposes of this research, criticisms of
the label of 'organised crime' as a unique or collective category have not been
assumed but have instead been assessed throughout the research process.
Clearly, definitional issues around terminology of organised crime and mafia
identities occupy a large part of the study.
The research findings are aligned with the theoretical framework of
comparative research in criminal justice, with a first stage analysis of the systems
under scrutiny and a second stage analysis of the convergences and divergences
between the two systems. At the first level are therefore be the two national
models - the Italian Structure Model and the English Activity Model -
constructed on the basis of legislation and institutional perceptions gathered
from interviews and documents. At the second level is the' proper comparative
effort to identify convergences and divergences of policies and practices between
the two states. Such comparative exercise does not only improve our
understanding of national approaches, beyond cultural, linguistic and legal
'boundaries, but can also improve the dialogue towards concerted efforts at the
international level.
Nevertheless, globalisation of criminal markets and internationalisation of
policies have influenced perceptions of organised crime and related policing
tactics also at national levels. This research has considered the influence of
international perspectives on convergences and divergences between the two
models. Including international perspectives completes this study through an
enhanced understanding of both models and with a view to highlight policy
recommendations for both countries.
|