Title:
|
The Irish Boundary Commission episode : northern
nationalist narratives and political culture 1924-1939
|
This research examines the significance of the Irish Boundary Commission
'episode' (July 1924 to December 1925) for Northern Ireland's nationalists. It
tests the thesis that the inter-governmental agreement following the
Commission's collapse in late 1925 - the agreement which cemented the
1920 border - was 'the key foundational moment' for the northern minority
between December 1925 and 1939. Some writers view the episode as an
important development in a larger story about partition generally: others
recognise its deep significance for northern nationalists. But the literature says
little about the construction and development of (often competing) nationalist
narratives which flowed from it. There is no in-depth analysis of how it came to
be remembered and shaped mind sets. The research interrogates, integrates
and deploys archival material to produce a finer-grained reading of the period;
and shows how arrangement of memories underpins narrative development.
The dissertation considers how narratives about 1924/25 subsequently
featured in political and popular discourse. In explaining the political culture
which developed, it explores the relationships between the principal nationalist
influences in the north and the two main political parties in the Irish Free
State. The later chapters devote particular attention to the increasingly
troubled relationship between border nationalists (especially in Fermanagh
and Tyrone) and the• early Fianna Fail governments, led by de Valera. The
research comments on clerical influence and engagement; and underscores
the strength of the press in reinforcing cultural messages and values, and in
fostering a sense of community. It offers an interpretation of why and how
narratives about late 1925 so powerfully shaped the northern minority's
attitudes and responses in later years. The dissertation concludes that, for
northern nationalists, the episode, culminating in the December 1925 pact,
had remained the organising principle in their political culture.
|