Title:
|
Revolutionary neighbourhoods and networks during the Paris Commune of 1871
|
This thesis explores the profile and practice of revolutionaries of the Paris
Commune and their variation according to local context. A micro-study was
made of three revolutionary neighbourhoods: Popincourt, Belleville and La
Villette. Micro-study from the angle of the arrondissement reveals the networks
of the middle-ranking men who controlled the revolution in each district. A core
of revolutionaries was identified and subjected to prosopographical profiling.
From detailed study of the main actors, their networks, their profile and their
practices, models of revolutionary typology have been postulated. The conseil
de guerre dossiers, despite the usual flaws in judicial sources, present the
richest material for this project. The networks of the accused can be extracted
from the dossiers, and the sociological data they contain used in
prosopographical analysis.
In Popincourt, the model was that of a virtuous revolutionary: skilled
artisans and settled family men embedded in their quartier. Emerging through a
quasi-democratic local committee structure, the revolutionaries kept control of
the revolution. They avoided violence, and instead worked together to make
improvements to their neighbourhood. By contrast, in Belleville the model was
that of a demagogic revolutionary. The revolutionary network was focused on
one charismatic individual who parachuted his minions into power. These men
were dec/asses who viewed the revolution as a means of ameliorating their
circumstances. They whipped up the crowd against the enemies of the
revolution, culminating in the massacre of hostages in the rue Haxo. Finally, in
La Villette there was a hybrid model composed of local activists and a Jacobin
infiltration from outside the neighbourhood. This provoked a schism during the
Commune and led to paralysis in the revolution. Though the Jacobins controlled
the arrondissement, they were unable to rally local support and could not
mobilize the migrant element of the Villettois population.
|