Title:
|
A randomised controlled trial of a novel self-help stress reduction manual for the middle management population
|
Stress and stress-related disorders have been on the increase both in the UK and
worldwide. UK Governmental bodies have proposed guidelines for managing stress at
work; however most are aimed at reducing and preventing stress in employees. There
are also a number of stress management programmes in place (including self-help), but
very few have been empirically validated in a middle management population.
A novel stress self-help manual based on cognitive behavioural therapy was developed
for middle managers and evaluated in this randomised controlled trial (RCT; N = 102).
Four outcome measures were used to measure change: Brief Symptom Inventory (BSI;
primary outcome measure), Symptom Assessment-45 (SA45), Coping Inventory for
Stressful Situations (CISS), and the Job Stress Survey (JSS).
Treatment effects were evaluated using analyses of covariance (ANCOVA) with post-
treatment scores as dependent variables and pre-treatment scores as covariates.
Significant changes were obtained on the BSI (P<0.001) at post-treatment, as well as
on the SA45 (P<0.001) indicating intervention effectiveness regardless of the frequency
of work stressors and lack of organisational support remaining unchanged. Measures of
coping indicated that the intervention increased task, emotion, and distraction-oriented
coping styles (P<0.001). The intervention was not found to effect the avoidance-
oriented or social diversion coping styles. Regression analyses indicated that discussing
the manual with others during the treatment protocol had a significant effect on
outcomes, suggesting that future interventions should encourage groups within
organisations rather than individual participation, or using the manual as an adjunct to
various forms of psychological therapy. Qualitative data was also collated, which
revealed that the participants felt more in control and confident after working through the
manual.
While further evaluation by independent researchers is recommended, including cost
effectiveness analysis, the manual has shown initial effectiveness and is considered a
potentially useful tool for the development of improvements towards managing and
preventing stress.
|