Title:
|
An evaluation of the effectiveness of the planning system in securing the retention of village services in rural Devon
|
Despite national and local planning policies that seek to retain rural services, their loss from
Devon's villages has led to those communities becoming increasingly less sustainable and
self-sufficient. At both the national and the local level there is inadequate quantitative
information about the extent of the losses of particular services over time and of the
characteristics of those settlements most likely to be affected. The influence of wider
contexts, or drivers of change, within which the changes are occurring are also poorly
understood.
Although several Local Authorities have produced reports recording rural service loss they
seldom analyse these changes or seek to explain why such changes are occurring.
Accordingly, Local Authority planning officers, both in Devon and elsewhere, have an
evidence base of only limited value upon which to develop policy or evaluate individual
applications.
This thesis addresses the lack of local data and associated quantitative analyses and
provides a qualitative assessment of the wider influences on rural service loss. Data about
changes in rural services with Devon villages, collected from diverse sources, are subjected
to rigorous statistical analyses. These analyses show the differential loss of particular
services (Public Houses being markedly more resilient than Post Offices and shops), and
identify key factors associated with service loss, most notably population numbers.
In order better to understand the wider contexts influencing changes in rural service
provision, the influences of a number of themes are explored and assessed. These include:
demographic and socio-economic trends; changing retailing patterns; academic and
professional debates about the role of rural areas; the national planning policy context that
has since at least the early 1940s, and with changing rationales, been urban focused firmly
constraining development in the countryside; and the effectiveness of planning decision-
making at District Council level.
Whilst not offering a simple planning 'solution' to the decline in rural services the case is
made for reliable and up-to-date statistics to support objective decision-making and for the
explicit consideration of the impacts of wider drivers of change so that the challenges of
future potential service change can be more openly, objectively and constructively
addressed. Allied to an improved evidence base, further assessment of other models of
provision, such community-run and subsidised commercial operation, is urgently needed.
|