Use this URL to cite or link to this record in EThOS:
Title: Edinburgh and Glasgow : civic identity and rivalry, c.1752-1842
Author: Rapport, Helen M.
ISNI:       0000 0004 2736 7320
Awarding Body: University of Stirling
Current Institution: University of Stirling
Date of Award: 2012
Availability of Full Text:
Access from EThOS:
Access from Institution:
This thesis is the first in depth study that has been undertaken concerning Edinburgh and Glasgow’s identities and rivalry. It is not an economic or a social study driven solely by theory. Essentially, this is a cultural and political examination of Edinburgh and Glasgow’s identities and rivalry based on empirical evidence. It engages with theory where appropriate. Although 1752 – 1842 is the main framework for the period there are other considerations included before this period and after this timeframe. This study provides the reader with a better understanding of the ideas highlighted in the introduction and it also indicates the degrees of changes as well as continuity within the two cities. Therefore, this thesis is not a strict comparison of the two cities and neither does it provide for a complete contextual breakdown of every historical event over the course of every year. The primary focus is kept on an array of primary written sources about the two cities over the course of the period, with only brief reflections about other places, where it is deemed appropriate. The thesis is driven by the evidence it has uncovered in relation to identity and rivalry, and the study uses particular events and their impact on the two cities within a particular historical narrative. As it is a preliminary report of its kind, there are, of course, many gaps which are opportunities for further research. This is something that the conclusion of this thesis returns to. Identity and rivalry are words not attached to any particular corpus of research material but rather are buried in an array of primary sources that are wide-ranging and all encompassing. Most have been uncovered in individual collections and in the literature of the time, including newspapers, guidebooks, travellers’ accounts, civic histories, speeches, letters, and in entries for the Encyclopaedia Britannica and also the Old and New Statistical Accounts. Although historians may have examined some of this material it has not necessarily been employed by them to investigate how the cities’ identities and rivalry evolved. The period was influenced by the ideas birthed from the Enlightenment and Romanticism, by the impact of the French Revolutionary and Napoleonic Wars and by the intense processes harboured by urbanisation, industrialisation and by political and social change as the Georgian city became a Victorian one, so consideration of these important aspects must be afforded, as well as the particular historians’ ideas about them and how they affected cities like Edinburgh and Glasgow within a Scottish and a British context.
Supervisor: Dingwall, Helen M.; Hutchison, Iain G. C.; Jenkinson, Jacqueline Sponsor: SCRAN
Qualification Name: Thesis (Ph.D.) Qualification Level: Doctoral
EThOS ID:  DOI: Not available
Keywords: Edinburgh ; Glasgow ; Civic Identity ; Rivalry ; Visitors' perceptions ; National-Civic testimonies ; National identity ; Scottish identity ; British identity ; Local identity ; Monuments ; Commemorations ; Civic Histories ; Glasgow History ; Edinburgh History ; National characteristics, Scottish. ; Scotland Civilization. ; Scotland Civilization ; Edinburgh (Scotland) Intellectual life. ; Glasgow(Scotland) Intellectual life ; Edinburgh (Scotland) Intellectual life