Title:
|
Bronterre O'Brien, class and the advent of democratic anti-capitalism : the social and political ideas of Chartism's 'schoolmaster'
|
This thesis seeks to analyse the intellectual contribution of James Bronterre O'Brien to
working-class anti-capitalist political economy, while placing it in its true historical
and intellectual context. In so doing, the thesis aims to fill significant gaps left by
O'Brien's biographer, Alfred Plummer, who dealt only cursorily with O'Brien's ideas.
In contrast to past accounts of O'Brien, which tended to analyse him purely in terms
of his significance vis-a-vis Marx, the thesis considers O'Brien's work on its own
terms, analysing both its continuities with early nineteenth-century anti-capitalist
political economy, and the significant ways in which it marked a break from previous
work. In particular, the thesis argues that O'Brien evinced a uniquely broad vision of
the role democracy would play in the post-capitalist society; for in O'Brien's new
society democracy's remit was to extend far beyond Parliament. Further, O'Brien
took the nascent class analysis of Hall and others, and constructed his entire political
economy on the basis of a mature, and fully elaborated, antagonistic class model.
The originality of his analysis, it is argued, is intelligible only if sufficient attention is
paid both to the historical moment at which O'Brien began writing, and to his intimate
connection with the `Political Owenism' of Henry Hetherington and others within
organisations such as the NUWC. The concept of class allowed O'Brien to combine
Owen's environmentalism with the demonology of older, Cobbettite radicalism. He
was thus able to formulate a political economy which spoke to workers in a language
with which they were familiar, but which was also more relevant to the social and
economic realities of 1830s Britain. The thesis also considers the evolution of
O'Brien's vision of the good life during the 1830s and after, and argues that O'Brien's
relationship with his imagined audience is the crucial factor in this regard.
From 1841, a break occurred, with O'Brien now oscillating between his old analysis
and a liberal political economy criticising excessive taxation etc. rather than capitalism
per se. The reasons for this shift, and for O'Brien's eventual abandonment of
democracy in the late 1840s, are also explored
|