Title:
|
Who are the most vulnerable pupils at transition? : the impact of risk and resilience factors in the experiences and adjustment of school children after the move from primary to secondary school
|
The transition from primary to secondary school represents a significant rite of passage
for many young people in the UK every year. However, this transition has been linked
to negative educational, social and emotional outcomes for some pupils. To date
research has considered the impact of individual differences on adjustment to
secondary school in terms of single risk and protective factors, with little consideration
of the interaction between them.
A key aim of this study was to better understand the characteristics of pupils who are
vulnerable to negative outcomes during the primary-secondary transition. The current
study considered multiple risk and protective factors together within a framework of
resilience in order to investigate which pre-transfer factors were most predictive of
post-transfer school adjustment outcomes, assessed one term after transfer to
secondary school. The study also explored the combined impact of pre-transfer risk
and resilience factors upon secondary school adjustment by investigating possible
moderator relationships. A second aim of the study was to understand in more depth
the experiences of pupils already identified as vulnerable during transition.
A mixed method design was adopted, comprising two distinct stages. Within the first
stage, pupils completed questionnaires rating their resilience and school adjustment
both pre and post-transfer. In total 133 pupils completed questionnaires at both time
points. Teachers also rated the pupils' school adjustment and resilience at these times
and further information on pupil risk was collected via demographic information from
school records. During the second stage of the study, semi-structured interviews were
carried out with a subgroup of pupils identified as vulnerable based upon risk factors
prior to transfer.
Overall, the study found that predictors of less successful teacher-rated school
adjustment after transfer related to poor behaviour, low maths attainment and limited
problem solving abilities in primary school. Less successful pupil-rated school
adjustment outcomes were predicted by perceptions of low levels of support and
problem solving skills, as well as difficulties in controlling emotional reactions and
maintaining emotional stability prior to transfer. The study also highlighted the potential
complexity involved in supporting pupils with SEN during transition. The findings
suggest that additional support in primary schools alone leaves SEN pupils less
prepared for the significant changes they face in their new secondary schools. Finally,
the semi-structured interviews revealed largely positive experiences of transfer,
suggesting that risk factors alone are insufficient in identifying vulnerable pupils at
transition.
|