Title:
|
Peer learning in the practices setting : issues of companionship, collaboration and contrast
|
The components of peer assisted learning (PAL) in the practice setting
have not been previously defined, since research has hitherto focussed
on outcomes, rather than construction. Whilst socio-cognitive and sociocultural
development theory underpins the development of PAL in both the
classroom and practice context, learner choice and flexibility are more
evident in the latter: activities are selected by the learner and their student
peer, according to personal preference and context, usually without tutor
supervision or prior scripting. These are more akin to workplace learning
practices than to the classroom.
Drawing on data from a triple phased, flexible research design (comprising
qualitative interviews, a collective case study and two Q-method studies
with undergraduate physiotherapy students from a range of programmes),
the activities, behaviours and perceptions of students engaged in PAL in
the practice setting are presented in three themes. Companionship casts
the peer as a buddy and ally, who helps create a supportive, emotional
landscape that prepares for, and sustains, learning. In Collaboration, as
learning partners, peers engage in a range of dialogic and activityorientated
behaviours which mediate learning through processes of
construction and co-construction. In Contrast, peer relationships are
enacted according to issues of comparison, competition and conflict.
The range of activities and behaviours involved in PAL in the practice
setting are consistent across clinical areas, level of student and type of
programme. Most students value PAL highly, and successful partnerships
are enabled by factors that include mutual trust, respect, compatibility and
a commitment to negotiating the shared learning experience.
This research contributes new knowledge by extending the application of
extant theory, providing a new framework by which PAL in the practice
setting may be identified, and a taxonomy that describes its roles and
activities. This will inform and prepare academics, clinicians and students
engaging in practice-based PAL, and will provide both a foundation for its
broader application, and a baseline for further research.
|