Title:
|
Invalid lives : disability, masculinity and consumptive identity in nineteenth-century culture
|
Focussing on texts produced between the publication of Rene Laennec's Treatise
on Diseases of the Chest and on Mediate Auscultation (1819; trans. 1821), and
the emergence of a law demanding compulsory notification of all cases of
pulmonary tuberculosis in 1912, this thesis examines the ways in which evolving
cultural discourses surrounding tuberculosis affected the identities of men with
this impairment. Many of the texts analysed in this thesis refuse to naturalise any
one cultural model of consumptive identity, depicting consumptives who are
themselves aware of the cultural pressures shaping their identity. My thesis
shows that their exposure of hitherto naturalised social discrimination constitutes
a `social model' of disability and, therefore, an early demonstration of disability
theory working within nineteenth-century texts.
In Chapter 1,1 analyse nineteenth-century social history documents, advice
books written for consumptives and their carers, mainstream medical textbooks,
and eugenic texts depicting the emerging biomedical model of tuberculosis and
the disabling social marginalisation experienced by consumptive men.
Chapter 2 examines letters and near-contemporary biographical and critical
material discussing poet John Keats (1795-1821) and artist Aubrey Beardsley
(1872-1898) to explore the ways in which nineteenth-century consumptives
could interact with prevailing cultural stereotypes.
Chapter 3 focuses on the characterisation of Linton Heathcliff in Emily
Bronte's Wuthering Heights (1847), analysing the disruptive potential of
juxtaposing traditional Romantic and sentimental models of disability with new
models of disease as a mundane biological phenomenon.
Chapter 4 focuses on the consumptive's outraged response to a new,
distinctively Darwinian deity called `Nature' in Fyodor Dostoevsky's The Idiot
(1869) and Thomas Hardy's Jude the Obscure (1895).
In Chapter 5I discuss the ways in which Beatrice Harraden's Ships That Pass
in the Night (1893) approaches the problem of conceptualising a disabled identity
as one generated through negative social `damage' and yet still worthy of
validation. Ships presents the struggle for valid disabled identity as analogous
with the situation of women seeking self-realisation and social equality in the
1890s.
My thesis offers the potential to redefine `positive' representation of disabled
identity according to criteria more coherently theorised than elsewhere in
disability studies. Many of the texts explored in my thesis undermine disabling
cultural structures not by presenting flattering or `realistic' images of disability,
but by presenting disruptive ways of performing the negative, unrealistic and
clichdd consumptive identities available in nineteenth-century culture. My focus
on deployment rather than content of cultural identities has allowed this thesis to
redefine the political radicalism of nineteenth-century texts - and people -
hitherto ignored by the modem disability movement. Exploiting historical and
moral chinks in the armour of traditional essentialist models of disability, these
`negative' identities demonstrate a degree of socio-political consciousness that
would only re-emerge in disability criticism at the end of the twentieth century
|