Title:
|
Priests in the making or priests already? : life stories of candidates for ordination in the Church of England
|
At a time when the Church of England was encouraging a greater variety of forms
of professional ministry, but still retained selection criteria reflecting earlier
organizational norms, my diocesan work with ordination candidates became a
journey of exploration worth taking whatever the outcome. In this context, I
collected rich life-story narratives using the Biographic-Narrative Interpretive
Method, twenty-one of which later became the raw material for this study. As I
began my research, I noticed in Michel Foucault's 1981-2 lectures at the College de
France, published as The Hermeneutics of the Subject, significant correspondences
between his concern with the relationship between the subject and truth, and the
narratives of those with whom I had worked in the ministerial vocational context.
I asked the central research question: Do these narratives of religious subjects
show signs of a concern for the relationship between the subject and truth - of the
subject progressively aligning itself with the truth that it thinks? I argued that, in
spite of Foucault's assertion in his lectures that Western theology is fundamentally
inimical to the survival of that 'spirituality' he sees as the progressive alignment of
the self with truth, his extension of the term 'spiritual exercises' used by Pierre
Hadot opens the way for a new theological appreciation of philosophy as a way of
life. I found, by posing to the narrative material six questions designed to test the
presence of 'spirituality' in the lives of ordination candidates, that the idea of the
progressive alignment of the self with truth seemed to be alive and well in
vocational theological discourse. This conclusion was reinforced at the
institutional level by my discourse analysis of a vocational publication, Ministry in
the Church of England. Having conducted semi-structured interviews with my
subjects, which confirmed my findings further, I then discovered, in a detailed
narrative analysis of all the interview material provided by four selected subjects,
evidence for the self-constituting capability of narrative as a 'spiritual practice of
the self'.
|