Title:
|
Social mobility, masculinity and popular music : the case of glam rock
|
Since its emergence in the early seventies, glam rock has been
theoretically categorized as a moment in British popular culture in which
essentialist ideas about male gendered identity in particular were rendered
problematic for a popular music audience. In providing both a discursive
reading of glam during the period 1971-1974 and new research on glam's
influence on its male working-class fans, I argue that whilst this reading of
glam is valid, insufficient attention has been given to an examination of the
relevance of social mobility vis-ä-vis the construction of self-identity in
relation to glam. My thesis is therefore concerned with raising questions
about social class in addition to interrogating questions of gender.
In undertaking a study of the ethno-biographies of a sample of glam's
original working-class male fans, the thesis contends that glam's political
significance is better understood as a moment in popular culture in which
an educationally aspirant section of the male working class sought to
express its difference by identifying with the self-conscious performance of
a more feminized masculinity it located in glam.
This rearticulation of masculinity, performed by an increasingly self reflexive
subject, alive to the social and cultural upheavals of the period,
was discursively represented as a modern development in contrast to the
dominant representations of working-class masculinity - bound by tradition
and community and thus essentialized as resolutely masculine - that had
until that historical moment enjoyed hegemonic status. The thesis argues
that the modem/unmodern dialectic at play here was replicated in glam's
divergent artistic factions, which aligned themselves to competing
aesthetic positions. In critiquing this process, the thesis engages with the
work of Bourdieu (1993a, 2003,2007a) to raise questions about how this
transition from unmodern to modern was affectively experienced by glam's
male fans.
The thesis concludes with an examination of glam rock's legacies in
respect of more recent performances of masculinity by working-class
young men seeking mobility. Finally, it draws on Skeggs' (2004) work to
argue that class-based identities are always fixed by the more powerful
other in order to be morally judged.
|