Title:
|
Reading recovery and children's writing : developing the writing of children with literacy learning difficulties
|
This thesis comprises a three-part longitudinal study of a one-to-one
literacy intervention programme for children having difficulty reading and
writing after one year at school. The programme, named Reading Recovery
and founded by Marie Clay, consists of daily half-hour lessons taught by a
teacher trained to diagnose and support children's problem-solving
approaches to reading and writing.
Children's writing development in Reading Recovery is the main focus of
this thesis. The first two sections of the thesis review writing development,
the Reading Recovery programme, and scaffolding.
The third section presents a year long comparison of Reading Recovery
children's writing with the writing from a comparison group of children
who scored equally low on a battery of tests but who did not receive
tutoring. Writing samples from classroom activities were collected from
children in both groups, divided into four phases through the year and were
scored on a scale by two raters. Statistical analyses showed improved
performance by children in Reading Recovery on five dimensions of writing
criteria with six levels of attainment. This development emerged in the
latter part of the year and indicates that Reading Recovery children
successfully transfer their increasing ability and independence to other
writing events where the Reading Recovery teacher is not present to
provide intensive support.
This section also includes the second empirical study, an investigation into
children's views on literacy. An interview on writing and reading was
conducted with children in both groups at the end of the longitudinal studies. Findings indicated a greater metalinguistic awareness and level
of sophistication of word awareness and analysis in the Reading Recovery
children's approach to print.
The fourth section of the thesis explores the interactive structure of
Reading Recovery lessons. Clay claims the programme is consistent
with the principles ofVygotsky's theory on the acquisition of cultural
tools. More specifically Clay and Cazden (1990) have shown how the
features of Reading Recovery lessons exemplify the scaffolding of
learning based on assessment of each child's current reading strategies
and techniques for moving the child towards independence in writing
and reading. In this year-long observation, Reading Recovery lessons
were studied using a sample of 17 children taught by seven trained
teachers. The writing episodes of the lessons were qualitatively
analysed. Teacher utterances were categorised and text-generation
topics and styles, talk-cycles and rehearsal routines were identified.
These are discussed in the light of the scaffolding literature. Although
the writing episodes conformed to many aspects of scaffolding, some
reconceptualisation is necessary to take account of the dynamic nature
of literacy learning in contrast with scaffolding within brief,
experimental tasks.
In the light of the findings from the three studies and drawing them
together, teaching and learning strategies are discussed, the importance of
the process of learning to write is emphasised and recommendations for
further research are made.
|