Title:
|
Founders, floods and fathers : narratives of origins and renewal in Florentine art and culture
|
This dissertation explores the understanding of origins in late medieval and Renaissance
Florence as represented in art and in wider fields of literary and historiographic
discourse. Its particular focus is a myth associating the foundation of Tuscany with
Noah, which was promoted in a volume of forged texts published by Annius of Viterbo
in 1498. Rather than focusing on Annius or his scholarly reception as other writers have
done, the thesis attempts to set the myths that he publicised in the context of other
stories about origins that circulated in Renaissance Florence. The central part of the
thesis consists of three chapters each of which takes its lead from a particular science of
origins: etymology, genealogy and archaeology. The topics discussed in them, however,
range beyond the strict confines of these disciplines to include such themes as: the
shifting narratives of the foundation of Florence; family history as recorded in
Florentine ricordanze; portraits as an expression of patrilineal ideology; and the legend
of the Florentine Baptistery as a former temple of Mars together with its influence on
Renaissance architecture. A recurring theme in these chapters is that of the origin
narrative as a myth that serves to justify present-day arrangements or identities. The
final chapter develops the theme of origins to encompass ideas of historical recurrence
and renewal. In a discussion that draws heavily on the writings of Machiavelli I attempt
to show that Florentine cyclical conceptions of history relied on a model of returning to
the origin. The chapter closes with a discussion of Renaissance artists who were either
perceived as the re-embodiment of an artistic ancestor, a 'new Giotto' for example, or
who actively strove to attain such a status. Finally, the conclusion attempts to draw
connections between a number of the narratives discussed earlier in the thesis on the
basis of a shared fantasy of autonomous male creativity
|