Title:
|
Nutrient characteristics of urban stormwater detention ponds on the Canadian Prairies
|
The use of artificial ponds for the temporary storage of urban stormwater
runoff is a commonly used environmental engineering practice in North America.
By releasing runoff at a rate slower than the initial generation rate, on-line flood
control is achieved. Urban runoff typically has a high eutrophication potential, so
that single unit detention ponds may sustain excess algal/macrophyte growth
within only a few years of construction. A research project was undertaken
between 1992 and 1995 on stormwater detention ponds in the Province of
Saskatchewan, Canada. Three ponds aged 15 to 17 years old are described in
this thesis. The focus of the study was to describe the nutrient characteristics
and associated phytoplankton cycles within these systems, and to further identify
potential management options for water quality improvement.
Four to five months of permanent winter ice cover occurs in the central
zone of the Province. Of the three systems reported here, complete winter
anoxia is typical in two (1.7 to 1.8 m deep - mixed), while partial or complete
anoxia occurs in the third pond according to the timing of snowmelt (2.7 m deepthermally
stratified in summer). Therefore, biological community structure is
limited by the overwintering potential. Accumulated nitrogen, phosphorus, and
silica sustained green algae and diatom blooms following ice-melt, and pH
values of >9.5 often occurred by late April. During the open water season,
hypereutrophic conditions were sustained and the systems typically oscillated
between blue-green and green algal dominance according to flushing, external
N- loading and mixing. Dissolved inorganic nitrogen:phosphorus (DIN:DIP)
ratios of stormwater were typically below Redfield stoichiometry. Therefore, inpond
DIN:DIP ratios of <3 were typical, with one system frequently <1. These
low ratios were the result of both internal P-Ioading and N loss mechanisms
during dry weather storage periods, and DIP >0.25 mg/L sometimes occurred
within the euphotic zone. Dense N-fixing Anabaena sp. blooms periodically
developed under suitable climatic conditions. Nitrogen fixed into the system in
turn supported non-fixing species as a subsiding bloom was mineralized.
Nutrient and phytoplankton cycles fluctuated within short time scales, according
to physical disturbances and algal self-shading at peak biomass (sometimes
> 100 mm3/L). Average algal biomass levels in the stratifying pond were lower than the other ponds on account of sedimentary losses to an anaerobic bottom
zone.
xv
Grazing by herbivorous zooplankton was generally not significant in
promoting phytoplankton species successions. The zooplankton of all three
systems were dominated by cyclopoid copepods and rotifers. Predation by fish
(minnows), food quality (blue-green algae dominance), and losses during large
flushing events are among factors which may suppress desirable large-bodied
cladoceran zooplankton in these systems.
The mean surficial (1 cm) sediment iron content was lowest (",,27 mg Fe/g
dry wt VS. 38 mg Fe/g dry wt) and the organic content was highest ("" 18% LOI VS.
11 % LOI) in the stratifying pond compared to the two non-stratifying ponds.
Also, the mean sediment depth in the stratifying pond (not including the littoral
slope sediments) was highest (",,21 cm VS. 9 to 13 cm), when compared to the
two non-stratifying ponds. Iron may be lost from the stratifying pond by flushing
of anaerobic hypolimnetic waters during stormflows. Groundwater inflows to the
stratified pond resulted in a higher alkalinity system and consequently the
highest mean sediment calcium content of the three ponds (",,82 mg Calg dry wt,
VS. 31 to 34 mg Calg dry wt). The surficial sediment total-P [TP] of the three
ponds ranged from 0.97 to 1.26 mg/g dry wt, and in all cases 11 to 15% of this
was associated with inorganic extractable P, with more in the calcium than the
iron/aluminium bound fraction.
At peak water temperatures (s:26°C) internal P loading rates >30
mg/m2/day were calculated from field data in the non-stratifying ponds. An
average P release rate of 15 mg/m2/day was measured during anaerobic
incubation of sediment cores from one of these ponds at 20°C. However,
aerobic incubation of these sediments showed that Fe concentrations were
sufficient to provide high P uptake potential when oxidized. Anaerobic
incubations of intact cores from the stratifying pond gave average release rates
of 5 to 16 mg/m2/day from 5 to 20°C. Field data also showed that net internal P
loads were reflected by changes in the surficial sediment P pool.
A nutrient input budget for the stratifying pond showed that groundwater
baseflow supplied a massive amount of DIN (as N03) relative to stormflows. If
the seasonal stormwater DIP load was expressed as an averaged areal
mass/day, the average seasonal internal P loading (-8 to 10 mg/m2/day) was four times higher. Theoretical P removal efficiencies of 63 to 80% were
calculated for the ponds, but resuspension and flushing of internally loaded P
accumulated during dry weather may reduce these values. A TP mass export of
0.25 to 0.3 kg/ha impervious/0.58 year from 250 mm precipitation was calculated
from runoff studies in Saskatoon.
In experimental work, inorganic nitrogen additions to the most N-limited
pond were carried out from May to July 1994. Complete dominance of the spring
to mid-summer phytoplankton by green algae and diatoms was maintained.
However, warming water increased P recycling, and during a period of lower
than average wind speeds a non-fixing blue-green algae bloom developed in
place of the usual N-fixing algae bloom. No significant alteration to the
zooplankton species composition was evident despite structural changes to the
vernal phytoplankton composition.
Phosphorus inactivation with aluminium sulphate was successful in
improving water quality for a six week period during which the control pond
developed a dense N-fixing algae bloom. Sediment surface oxidation was
promoted by the reduction of productivity, and P adsorption to sediment iron
complexes was an important secondary benefit. Several very large storms were
ultimately responsible for exchanging approximately 100% of the storage
volume, after which bloom conditions were restored. The procedure may be an
effective short-term measure, but benefits will not extend beyond major
exchange events.
Management options for aesthetic improvement are very limited in these
hypereutrophic ponds. External DIP loads will continue to be at least 5 to 10
times greater than threshold values for nuisance algal growth, and seasonal
internal loading of P is high. The inability of increased N availability to prevent
blue-green algae bloom formation, together with high exchange volumes and a
general lack of herbivorous zooplankton, suggest that top-down management
interventions (limited by overwintering) to control zooplanktivores are unlikely to
prevent algae bloom formation in ponds with lower volume:catchment area
ratios.
More work is required with regard to nutrient budgets if pond operational
efficiencies are to be accurately assessed. In addition, measurement of primary
productivity would provide invaluable information for any attempt to model algal growth in these ponds. Sediment removal is ultimately required as a long-term
maintenance measure, but more information on the incorporation of P
inactivation agents directly into the sediment structure is needed as a means to
retard internal P loading.
|