Title:
|
Small business development as a strategy for empowerment in post-apartheid South Africa
|
Black Economic Empowerment (BEE) is one of the most contested transformation
programmes of post-apartheid South Africa. The empowerment process was the result of
centuries of disempowerment of the majority of the population, a process intensified and
institutionalised when the National Party came to power in 1948. Due to the bargained
transition, however, the first phase of BEE was driven by the private sector with minimal
government intervention. At this point it was primarily focused on equity transfer, ownership
and the promotion of blacks into management positions. As a result of heavy criticism and the
collapse of a number of BEE companies during the 1997-8 economic crisis, there were strong
demands to redefine the programme to achieve genuinely broad-based empowerment, and for
government intervention to support it. This resulted in the Broad-based Black Economic
Empowerment Act of 2003.
Based on the understanding that the political and economic system has shaped various
policies in post-apartheid South Africa, this study takes a political economy approach to
examine the development of black-owned small business as a strategy for the empowerment
of the majority. It is structured into three interlinking parts. The first provides the historical
context, examining the foundations of the present empowerment process. The second
explores the trajectories of power that led to the policies of small business development and
broad-based economic empowerment. The third considers the implementation process
through the investigation of national and provincial empowerment institutions, private sector
participation and the extent to which an entrepreneurial culture exists in South Africa. Taken
together these seek to answer the primary question of how the political and economic system
is affecting the development of black-owned enterprises for broad-based empowerment.
Methodologically this research adopts a critical realist approach, and utilises triangulation
techniques to analyse multiple sources of evidence, such as the critical deconstruction of
various written sources including legal, archival, media and policy documents. Primary data
was acquired through a qualitative approach combining observation, informal interactions;
formal in-depth interviews with key informants, and seminars and conference notes. A case
study approach has been used to give detailed explanations of some of the complex causal
relations in real-life and empowerment interventions. This approach helps link theoretical
discourses on empowerment, policy and entrepreneurship in the study framework with the
realities of the political and economic interactions in the empowerment process.
The findings of this study show that contrary to general assumption, ideology and economic
interest rather than race shaped the two policies. Even though the BBEE policy process was
completely carried out by blacks, it has still retained its minimalist approach. The policy
document portrays two ambiguous approaches: a broad-based strategy that targets a few and a
broad-based strategy that targets the majority. However, the mechanism for implementing the
programme favours the former. The implication is that rather than an integrated approach to
developing black-owned businesses that recognises the diversity of the disempowered group,
the process takes a macro and market-oriented approach to empowerment that is focused on
promoting small, medium and large enterprises, and is therefore not yielding a genuine
empowerment dividend for the majority of the targeted group. Although there is an indication
that empowerment could reach the majority at the grass-roots level through micro enterprises
and the cooperative movement, insufficient resources are being invested in this sector.
Finally, the limited political engagement of civil society organisations is contributing to the
continued neglect of the majority of disempowered blacks in the empowerment process.
|