Title:
|
Culture, power and development disconnect in the central highlands of Madagascar
|
In order to understand why development projects fail on a regular basis - or at least fail to
achieve their intended goals - it is important to investigate not only the apparatuses of
development (work related aspects such as documents, reports, policies, programmes and
projects), but also the social and cultural worlds of the different actors involved. This means
expanding the analysis beyond critiques of development that focus on discourse analysis of
project documents and interface analysis which produce in-depth ethnographies of those
being "targeted' for development; it means also focusing attention on those who are doing the
actual "targeting'.
This thesis studies how different groups of actors engage in the same material reality - that of
the natural environment in rural Madagascar. It is a multi-sited ethnography that explores the
culture and lives of Betsileo farmers living and working in the Central Highlands of
Madagascar, as well as various development practitioners living and working on development
projects and programmes concerned with the management of those same natural resources
and livelihoods. The research focuses on three inter-related sites and traces development
relations and interactions from the central locations of the development machine to its
extremeties: several villages around one rural town in the Central Highlands called
Ambalavao, the provincial capital of Fianarantsoa, and the capital of the country,
Antananarivo. And it maps out the social and work relations of various actors as they engage
in rice cultivation and the management of dams and irrigation works with various degrees of
knowledge, capacities and power. The focus is not on anyone development project or
programme, but the various relationships - or lack thereof - between different actors, domains
of science, knowledge and various meanings given to them. It is also a commentary on the
wider global and bilateral political-economic relations that both limit and structure what
development ends up doing - or not doing.
|