Title:
|
A Latecomer's Transition to a Renewable Energy Society : The Shaping of the New & Renewable Energy Technology Program (NRETP) in Korea
|
The thesis has looked at the evolution of New & Renewable Energy Technology Program
(NRETP) in Korea. It has analysed various factors shaping the program. In particular,
the reasons, the interactions and the contributions of the participation of the
environmental NOOs in the governance structure of the program are critically examined.
The coalition between the industry and the government invited the environmental NOOs
to join the coalition. The objective of new & renewable energy industry development has
created the resource-based coalition upon which the value-based coalition was built.
The government has dramatically increased its expenditure on the development of new &
renewable energy technology which corresponded by the industry with similar amount of
investment. The participation of the environmental NOOs in the governance structure
of NRETP, however, would not have been possible without the adoption of the
governance approach by the government. T he authoritarian developmental state has
been changing to meet the demand from the civil society. The changes in the
governance structure opened the window of opportunity which enabled the NOOs to take
part and put their visions and ideas into the NRETP.
In relation to the production of technology variety, however, the contribution of the
NOOs has been minimal. They did not seem to have a clear visions or strategy
regarding the production of technology variety. In addition, the objective and strategy
of technology development has already been largely set before the NOOs' participation.
Furthermore, the members from the academic community strongly supported the
technology development strategy which was largely based on the strategy of large firms.
The contest of cognitive frameworks of the participants was not serious. The
participation . has reached the normative mode and instrumental mode realizing
democratic rationale, yet leaving the substantive mode and large portion of technocratic
rationale unattained.
With regards to the technology diffusion, the participation of NOOs has made a
difference. The contest of cognitive framework was serious. Their visions and ideas
coming from other ways of knowing the world in addition to scientific and technological
knowledge has been put forward and integrated into the output of the NRETP in the form
of small scale electric power generators, the user variety. The on-site generation and
frugal use of energy, their lifestyle choice, has become tangible making impacts on the
existing social order: the centralised energy generation and distribution at the· system
level and the high intensity of material & energy use of modern life at individual
behavioural level. Although one environmental NOO stopped participating, the
participation has reached the substantive mode realizing the technocratic rationale, coproducing
the technology and new social order.
|