Title:
|
Offending Women in Stafford, 1880-1905 : Punishment, Reform and Re-integration
|
In contrast to the bulk of historical research on female offending, this thesis focuses,
in particular, on women's petty offending. The first objective of the research was to
redress the imbalance created by many previous studies that have highlighted the
sexually related offences of women and to establish the participation of women in less
overtly gendered crime. The analysis showed that women's offending was indeed
mundane in nature and reflected their limited opportunities for offending, but also
that, like men, women were largely summonsed for drunken and anti-social
behaviour, breaching increasing regulatory legislation, and common assault. The
second objective was to examine when and why women started to offend. The
analysis showed that the onset and exacerbation of offending was directly linked to
pressing social concerns and policing practices rather than an inherent criminality.
Conversely, the third objective was to examine why women stopped offending, if
indeed they did stop. The examination showed that reform and re-integration were not
symbiotic. Re-integration often led to persistence in offending, particularly if their
offending was a result of unhappy marital circumstances or alcohol-related. Reform
was only possible when women ceased to be summonsed, not necessarily when they
changed their behaviour. Criminal justice interventions were largely ineffective; a
large proportion of women who desisted from offending did so in spite of punishment,
not because of it.
|