Title:
|
Access for all? : case studies of how a local authority music service developed a wider opportunities music programme
|
This study into the wider opportunities pledge for instrumental music making has been
conducted over a six-year period within one North West Instrumental Music Service (lMS).
The aims of the study were primarily twofold, to look at large-scale pupil access to music
service instrumental lessons and to consider how a music service could be used to enrich the
school music curriculum. These two strands were investigated through a number of
developed activities formed into a series of case studies; three of which are detailed within
this thesis. One of these focused on methods of pupil curricular enrichment through themed
and informative concerts given to whole school communities. The other two investigated
methods of offering greater access to instrumental lessons to whole classes of children. A
philosophical rationale was developed and presented as a possible model through which to
support and justify these activities. The outcomes and conclusions from these cases in
conjunction with the philosophical rationale offer insights into issues of teacher identity,
staff training, organisation of instrumental services, as well as models for future practice and
pedagogy.
In this thesis I explore a series of methodological tools and how they have aided the
collection of data, its analysis and the resulting understanding I have gained. I describe how
an overarching Action Research methodology is used to frame and develop a series of
related case studies, policy analysis and philosophical debate through a cyclical pattern of
identification, implementation and evaluation of practice (Elliott 1991). Data is viewed
through the socio-culturallearning theories of Wenger (1998) and Lave and Wenger (1991)
by seeing the class ensemble, the school, and the IMS as inter-related communities of
practice. By charting my understanding of aestheticism and praxialism I have been able to
ofTer a definition of the function of music and music education as well as a useable (in the
context of this thesis) philosophical rationale. The conclusions I draw inform and guide
some of the issues I have encountered during this study. This element of the thesis lays bare
some of my own theoretical experiences and interpretations on its course towards an
understanding of how this educational phenomenon can be explained and supported through
theory.
The main research findings are drawn together from the conclusions made in a number of
chapters. National Education policy and legislation is viewed through its interpretation and
implementation at the local level. These external forces have created a unique service
structure and modes of operation that shape the manner of engagement with children.
Outcomes of case studies are used to forward understanding by offering insights that
illuminate how organisations can model learning communities that demonstrate musical life,
pleasure and understanding with large groups of children. The design of these cases
encouraged a refinement of teaching approaches and the development of musical identities
in both pupils and teachers alike. The thesis concludes by charting my personal development
through this course of study. It comments retrospectively on my learning and the growth of
understanding for scholarly enquiry, musical and educational knowledge. It also makes
suggestions as to which avenues of further investigation this study could possibly lead to for
others or myself.
|