Title:
|
Accessing Oxbridge : a capability assessment of the widening participation agenda
|
This thesis examines the enduring issue of widening participation at the Universities
of Oxford and Cambridge (commonly elided as Oxbridge) and considers: the real
opportunities students from non-traditional backgrounds have to consider, apply to
and progress to Oxbridge; and what enhances and inhibits those opportunities. The
thesis draws on two research projects. The first specifically addresses these issues.
The second, and more recent, addressed them as part of its remit to consider widening
participation and the pedagogies of higher education at Cambridge. Both studies
made use of life history research and the thesis incorporates the life histories of six of
the participating students. Analysis of the data makes use of the capability approach,
developed by Amartya Sen and Martha Nussbaum, which is concerned with the
substantive freedoms - that is, the capabilities -people have to choose and lead lives
they value and have reason to value. The capability approach de-emphasises the
importance of commodities in well-being assessments but it has been criticised for
failing to pay proper attention to the social structures which influence the relative
value of educational commodities and the consequent freedom individuals have to
make use of them. Bourdieu's sociology of education is employed to address this
issue of social discipline. The data are analysed using his concept of capital -
specifically academic, cultural and symbolic capital - and the findings are then
discussed in relation to the preference deformation that inhibits the progression of
students from non-traditional backgrounds to Oxbridge and then the enhancement of
their capabilities. The capability focus on opportunity presents an even bleaker
assessment than the Bourdieusian focus on outcome: not only do proportionately
fewer students from the state-maintained sector progress to Oxbridge, the opportunity
gap is disproportionately greater when compared with their peers from the
independent sector. Nevertheless, successful interventions can enhance the freedoms
of individual widening participation students to take part in the life of the Oxbridge
community.
|