Title:
|
An Exploration of Some of the More Intangible Aspects of a School Facing Challenging Circumstances
|
This dissertation centres on a school facing challenging circumstances in Norfolk. The
school has a poor reputation locally and low examination results compared to national
figures and other local schools, but, despite this, the school is a welcoming and pleasant
place. This dissertation explores this apparent paradox between the schooPs reputation
and measured performance and the lived experience of staff and students by asking
participants to use photographs to talk about what they thought was 'special' about the
school.
Twenty seven Year 8 students and seven teachers were involved as participants in this
research. Student participants were asked to create individual mind maps about the things
they considered 'speciaP about the school, then in six self-selected groups they were
asked to photograph these 'special' aspects. The students were later interviewed in their
groups with their mind maps and photographs to elicit their views. The teacher
participants took photographs and were then interviewed individually. All participants
were asked not to take photographs of people.
It was found that the differing methods of research sometimes produced contrasting
ideas, however; 'people' were identified most consistently as being a 'special' aspect of
the school. Students valued their friendships while teachers valued the support of their
colleagues both past and present. There was some contrast, however, in how students and
teachers viewed the relationships they shared with each other; teachers tended to view
these more positively. Other aspects of the school that were considered 'special' were:
sport, school meals, the success of students, although this was not always measured
conventionally, and aspects of the environment in which the school was set.
Photographs were found to possess a powerful duality in enabling participants to talk
about both what was visible in the images and also what was invisible. This was
enhanced by some participants who developed creative and inventive ways of
representing people in their photographs without transgressing the 'no people' rule
imposed by the researcher. In addition to this there was an undercurrent of non-vocalised
data, which indicated the effort and commitment some participants gave to this research.
This dissertation ends with a consideration of the research methods and their
effectiveness in exploring some of the more intangible aspects of this and other schools
facing challenging circumstances.
|