Title:
|
Authentic performances and ambiguous identities : Gypsy musicians on the Greek Albanian border
|
This thesis addresses how tensions around the politics of othering and the marking of
'difference' constructed and pursued in and through music emerge and unfold in a place that
has been historically constructed and reconstructed as ambiguous/marginal and around people
who figure ambiguously in the national imaginary. Drawing on 14 months of fieldwork among
some of the gypsy musicians on the Greek-Albanian border, the Parakalamos gypsies, the
thesis explores how these tensions are being reformulated within the recent emphasis on
multiculturalism and cultural heritage in Greece.
A key concern is how place and its locatedness (physical and symbolic) are implicated
in processes of othering and are played out in and through music/music playing. It is proposed
that the ambiguities embedded in gypsy music playing are reinforced by and resonate with the
same ambiguities that permeate the construction of place. It is argued that for gypsies, this
process involves no 'separate' and 'self contained' gypsy 'culture' or identity. Instead, the thesis
argues that gypsy senses of 'be-longing' are manifested through ongoing encounters: located
and locating performances, which generate a sense of identification rather than a fixed identity.
An implication of this lack of a sense of fixed identity is that gypsies' marginality - what I call a
location in- between -does not entail the possibility of challenging hegemonic constructions of
identity It amounts instead to the catachresis (misuse and! or condemnation) of their
'difference'- its mis-recognition.
Ethnographically, the thesis focuses on two main areas. Firstly, there is an exploration
of the main processes involved in the embodied practices of using music to 'identity' people
and place and the way these are connected to the ambiguous/marginal character of place on
the Greek-Albanian border. Secondly, it explores the implications of such marginality for the
way inter-ethnic relations (between gypsies and non-gypsies) are experienced and practised.
|