Title:
|
How Damage Alters Meaning : An Analysis of the Conservation and Display of War-Damaged Objects in War Museums
|
War museums address many of the most controversial aspects of human history, some of
which have the potential to be viewed as contradictory, such as: the representation of both
the horrors of war and the heroics of soldiering; addressing the darkest aspects of
humanity in a context of enlightenment and learning; and - most importantly for this work -
depicting loss through the physical presence of material objects.
By examining, in-depth, a small selection of war-damaged objects this research explores
how some owner institutions have approached the conservation and display of these items
and the impact their choices have had on meaning and viewer interpretation. The
effectiveness of these treatment and display approaches is evaluated and the potential
implications of these methods for the significance and understanding of war-damaged
objects in general are examined.
This research shows that societal perceptions of war directly influence the way museums
conserve and display war-damaged objects. It demonstrates people's belief that individual,
war-damaged objects eloquently express the horrors of war. Our inability to grasp the
sheer scale of war means that we are best able to understand its devastating effects on an
individual level; viewers project their empathy onto war-damaged objects, as condition is
seen to mirror that of the victims of war. Personal items are the most effective trigger for
this empathic reaction, which is why war-damaged objects of this type are seldom
restored. This in turn has negated the perceived importance of war-damage to nonpersonal
items.
It is concluded that the symbolic associations attributed to war-damaged personal items
have sometimes clouded the judgment of museum professionals and resulted in a failure
to properly address the long-term preservation needs of the object. Conversely, the
devaluing of the importance of war-damage to non-personal items has sometimes resulted
in unsympathetic, interventive conservation
|