Title:
|
The impact of copper-chrome-arsenic (CCA) wood preservatives on non target marine organisms
|
The impact of two formulations of chromated copper arsenate (CCA) wood preservatives
(Celcure AO and Tanalith C33 10) on a range of marine organisms was assessedin both laboratory and
field investigations. As part of an EU project, a long-term field investigation was carried out exposing
test panels of Scots pine treated to 12,24 and 48 kgm -3 CCA and untreated controls at seven coastal sites
(Portsmouth, UK; Kristineberg, Sweden; La Tremblade (2 sites), France; Ria Formosa, Portugal; Sagres,
Portugal; Athens, Greece). Inspections were made at 6,12 and 18 months after submergence and the
fouling communities on CCA-treated and untreated panels were assessed both quantitatively and
qualitatively. Over the course of the field trial patterns of fouling that were common at several of the
sites were recorded. In the majority of cases there were no significant differences in species abundance,
species diversity, community organic biomass and total dry weight of fouling organisms on CCA-treated
versus untreated panels. However, a number of species were recorded in significantly higher numbers
on CCA-treated panels compared to untreated panels.
The extent and type of microbial degradation of these panels was also assessed. Sections from
the panels exposed for periods of 6,12 and 18 months were examined by light microscopy and the depth
of penetration by soft rot fungi and tunnelling and erosion bacteria was measured. Attack was found to
be heavy in untreated wood, but absent or very superficial in CCA-treated wood. The fungal flora was
also recorded after 6,12 and 18 months exposure following incubation of panels. Fungal diversity on
untreated wood was high, whereas on CCA-treated wood fungi were either absent, or a low diversity
present. The surfaces of untreated panels were notably softer as a result of microbial and marine borer
attack.
Scanning electron microscope studies revealed that the rate of biofilm formation on the surfaces
of CCA-treated panels (12,24 and 48 kgm -3 CCA) was marginally faster than on the surface of
untreated panels over a4 week exposure period in the sea at the Portsmouth exposure site. After 4
weeks of exposure no differences in biofilm composition were detectable between different panel
treatments.
Algal fouling was monitored on CCA-treated and untreated Scots pine panels after
submergence at the exposure site at Portsmouth, UK for a period of 4 weeks. In the majority of cases
there were no significant differences in the abundance of each algal species on CCA-treated or untreated
panels. Two species of algae were recorded in significantly lower abundance on CCA-treated panels
compared to untreated panels, suggesting that these species were sensitive to leached preservative from
the surfaces of the treated panels.
The impact of CCA-preservatives on invertebrate fouling was also monitored over the initial 4
weeks of submergence. Scots pine panels treated to 2,4,6,12,24 and 48 kgm -3 (Celcure AO and
Tanalith C3310), and untreated controls were exposed at a brackish water millpond, Emsworth, UK.
Settlement densities of 3 species of calcareous invertebrates were measured. Densities of the serpulid
Ficopomatus enigmaticus significantly increased with increasing CCA loading; numbers of the two
species of barnacle (Elminius modestus and Balanus crenatus) were also higher on CCA-treated panels
than on untreated panels but these differences were often not significant.
A laboratory leaching trial combining a static and a flowing seawater system was carried out to
measure the leaching rate of copper, chromium and arsenic from the surface of Scots pine panels treated
to 3,6,12,24 and 48 kgm-3 CCA. Losses of chromium and arsenic over the 10 week trial were very
low, whereas losses of copper were much higher. Copper losses from freshly treated panels were
highest, but rapidly fell to much lower levels after exposure in flowing seawater.
Laboratory bioassays were carried out to test the toxicity of leachates from CCA-treated wood,
or their toxic components. Tests on the thraustochytrid, Schizochytrium aggregatum, examined the
effects of copper ions on mortality of sporangia and motility and viability of zoospores. A very high
tolerance to copper ions was recorded in both instances. Experiments exposing spores/zygotes of two
species of marine algae found that concentrated leachates from CCA-treated wood inhibited germination
of Fucus serratus zygotes but only reduced the percentage germination of Undaria pinnatifida spores.
All of the bioassays used produced rapid results.
Data suggests that CCA-treated wood is not toxic to non-target marine fouling organisms.
Preferences to settle on CCA-treated wood over untreated wood by certain marine fouling organisms
may be due to differences in the surface properties of the wood (surface energy, biofilm formation)
influencing choice of settlement sites by fouling propagules. Differences manifested at this initial stage
of the fouling process may be reflected in the mature fouling community.
|