Title:
|
Earnings Management Practice in UK Mergers and Acquisitions
|
This study investigates the earnings management phenomena in Mergers and
Acquisitions (M&A) in the UK. The intention is to provide evidence of the occurrence
of earnings management practices prior to the completion of the deal process among
acquiring companies that issue shares as the purchase consideration, compared to those
that use cash. In addition, the study examines the performance of the share acquirers
against cash acquirers.
The existing academic literature relating to ,earnings management in US and Australian
M&A transactions appears to provide contradictory results. The existing literature for
the UK has anaysed the M&A position from a number of perspectives and reported
similar results. However, limited research has been carried out for UK M&A from an
earnings management perspective. Therefore, this study attempts to bridge the gap by
providing evidence of earnings management practice in M&A activities in the UK. By
using the accrual model, the results are directly comparable with existing research
studies for the US and Australia.
The main earnings management detection method used is this study is a modified
version of the Jones model developed by Dechow et al (1995). In addition to this, the
study investigates detection of earnings management by looking at 'other' measures and
attempts to explain the performance of these companies, using ratio analysis. A control
sample that uses cash as the purchase consideration is derived to compare the effect of
earnings management with that of the main sample that uses shares. The accounting and
market data for each company are obtained from Datastream for the time period of 1999
to 2003. The transaction values and the method of payment are gathered from different
sources: National Statistics Bureau, Journal Monthly Acquisition and Hemscott
premium websites.
The results obtained by using the modified Jones model and 'other' measures highlight a
positive and statistically significant difference between the share and cash sample. It
indicates that in the years prior to M&A, acquiring firms manage earnings upward. It can
be argued therefore that, acquiring firms' use accounting procedures in an attempt to
increase their stock price, prior to stock for stock merger or acquisition. In addition, ratio
analysis reveals that, firms that offer stock significantly under-perform those offering
cash.
Supplied by The British Library - 'The world's knowledge'
|