Title:
|
Christian Ideals of Manliness During the Period of the Evangelical Revival, c. 1730 to c. 1840
|
In this thesis it will be argued that there was considerable commonality to Christian
ideals of manliness during the period of the Evangelical Revival. At the core of the thesis is
the ideal ofthe imitation of Christ. It will be argued that this provided a central Christian ideal
ofpersonhood, and the thesis examin~s the variety ofways in which the ideal was interpreted
and understood. Crucially, variations did not tend to follow Church-party or denominational
lines. Chapter one looks at the imitation of Christ itself and the theological frameworks
within which it was understood, whilst the remaining five chapters take a broadly life-cycle
approach, examining the ways in which the ideal was applied to different aspects ofa man's
life. Although the thesis argues for commonality, this is not to suggest that commonalitY did
not come under strain. Indeed, it will be argued that some Christians were accused of
undermining or neglecting the imitation of Christ. There were two main sets of charges:
'enthusiasm' and 'moralism'. Both accusations were rooted in, and reflected, differences over
the theological frameworks for the imitation of Christ and disagreements over the strictness
with which ideals were developed in relation to the various aspects of a man's daily life.
There was also an overwhelming continuity to ideals through the eighteenth and early
nineteenth centuries. Within this framework there were however some developments. Most
importantly, in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries the term 'Evangelical',
having been synonymous with 'Christ-like' and 'the Gospel', acquired Church-party
associations. Furthermore, the theme of 'occasional' solitude was promoted from the 1760s
as a result ofconcerns about people taking pleasure in company. There were also some shifts
of emphasis. The late eighteenth century saw an intensification of the critique of 'moralism'.
This was particularly evident in criticisms of 'moral' preaching and also in concerns over the
teaching of the classics at the public schools. Educational ideals, more generally, were the
subject of considerable discussion from the 1780s. Finally, Christian ideals ofmanliness were
highly interconnected. The imitation of Christ was an all-encompassing ideal, and different
aspects of a man's life, and indeed death, were seen as linked. Particularly important is that
'the family' meant more than the nuclear unit of husband, wife and children, and could
operate metaphorically to include all aspects of social life.
|