Title:
|
Across a great divide : views of landscape and nature in the American West, before and after the cultural watershed of the 1960s and 1970s : Wallace Stegner and Cormac McCarthy
|
In this thesis my aim has been to establish a link between the western American
writers, Wallace Stegner and Cormac McCarthy. My point of connection has been the
treatment of landscape and nature in the works of both authors, and I have argued that
their works exemplify perspectives which are related to their authors' historical
positions before and after the cultural watershed of the Vietnam era. Although their
works are dissimilar in many ways, both writers have similar concerns with regard to
the western American landscape, and the social, political, and human ramifications of
, the myth of the frontier, and crucially, its effect on the natural world. I argue that
Stegner and McCarthy provide a link between the thinking of their respective eras·
which reveals changes related to the loss of faith in the culturally accepted archetypes
upon which much American thought was based prior to the upheavals ofthe era ofthe
Vietnam War, the 1960s and early 1970s. I believe that despite what might appear to
be contradictory narratives about the'West and the western landscape, the subtext in
both authors is a deep questioning of widely accepted western mythic imagery and its
continuing effect on American life and ideology.
While western mythology has been examined before, it has IJpt been discussed in
relation to these two authors seen as a pairing exemplifying a movement from the
more traditional realist narratives written prior to the Vietnam era, and the darker,
more pessimistic narratives of the post-Vietnam era, in which a loss of faith in many
previously accepted cultural givens became common. It might therefore seem
appropriate to describe Stegner and McCarthy as modernist and postmodern, but I
believe those terms simplify, obscure, and in a very real sense misname the complex
sets of issues and· traditions with which both authors deal from their vantage points
on either side ofthe divide which had as its defining moment the Vietnam War. I also
discuss the issue of the feminine in western landscape in the works of both authors.
Again, Stegner and McCarthy reveal a change in American thinking, not necessarily
entirely positive, which has as its fulcrum the 1960s and '70s, and included such
culturally momentous events as the civil rights movement, the women's movement, a
new, politicized environmentalism, and various other progressive movements.
The western American landscape has always had great significance in American
thinking, requiring an unlikely uniori between frontier mythology and the reality of a
fragile western environment. Both Stegner and McCarthy focus on this landscape and
environment; its spiritual, narrative, symbolic, imaginative, and ideological force is
central to their work. My goal has been to show how their various treatments ofthese
issues relate to the social climates in which they were written, and how despite
historical discontinuities, both Stegner and McCarthy reveal a similar unease about
the effects of the myth ofthe frontier on American thought and life.
|