Title:
|
A socio-historical analysis of violent combat sports in Japan with particular reference to the theory of the civilising process
|
The main aims of this thesis are to examine 'total fighting' (mixed martial arts),
which is becoming increasingly popular in Japan, from several different angles with
particular reference to the issue of violence, and, at the end, to evaluate the
appropriateness of an Eliasian framework, which is based upon the theory of the
civilising process, first suggested by Norbert Elias in his 1939 study, for
understanding a relatively contemporary spectator-oriented violent sport, such as
total fighting. Total fighting is widely regarded as a 'barbaric' form of sport which
cannot be accommodated within the realm of modem sport due to its apparently high
level of violence, cruelty and brutality. In this regard, the nature of this sport can be
said to contradict the understandings of those who support the theory, in which it is
claimed that modem sports are leading inexorably towards less violent, cruel and
brutal forms. This thesis has two dimensions: first, the development of combative
sports, such as bujutsu, budD and professional wrestling (all of which have a close
relationship to total fighting) as well as total fighting, was examined in order to
understand the emergence and growing popularity of total fighting in the 1990s in the
context of the historical development of combative sports in Japan; second, the case
study of total fighting itself was contextualised in the broader context of youth
culture and the issue of violence in contemporary Japan. These interrelated analyses
were informed by a period of exploratory fieldwork in Japan, during which the
practices of total fighting and its spectator appeal were observed, and this context
was reviewed in the light of a broader theoretical discussion concerning the theory of
the civilising process. This study is the first academic attempt to understand a
relatively new sport that emerged in the 1990s, and also makes a contribution tobroader sociological discussions concerrung the accuracy and usefulness of the
theory of the civilising process
|