Title:
|
The enchantment of laughter : comic effect in fiction and critical discourse
|
This thesis pursues the narrative codes and effects through which we sense,
and make sense of, instances of comedy in fiction. Its broad scope of
authorship - from Chaucer to Bret Easton Ellis - probes the contextual
dependency of comedy and 'senses of humour' as well as a seemingly
transcultural value of laughter. It draws on critical accounts of comedy, most
notably by Georges Bataille, Henri Bergson, Simon Critchley, Sigmund
Freud, Arthur Koestler and Julia Kristeva, exploring the ways in which our
experiences of reading comic narratives are shaped by such cultural
constructions of 'the comic'. It finds that genre and context specific studies
hinge as much on concerns of social and critical responsibility - the factors
that make the comic dimension of fiction valuable as opposed to frivolous -
as general theorisations of 'the comic'. This thesis is no exception. It aims to
counter criticism that, often armed with the phrase 'postmodern play',
interprets comic forces of destabilisation as dangerously annulling serious
social concerns. The first half of this study takes in turn three comic modes
that have come under critical fire: parody, irony and cynicism. The latter half
explores the consolidation and subversion of communal identities in comic
fiction through the subjects of Czech humour, translation and regional
accents. Throughout, it challenges conventional criticism that posits comedy
as a tool of social discrimination and laughter as an assertion of superiority_
Instead, it finds in comic narratives precisely the collapse of fixed critical
'standpoints' and the relativity of evaluations. Following Bataille, it proposes
that the 'enchantment' of laughter stems neither from an inflated sense of
self nor an escape from seriousness that leaves us spellbound, but from an
unsettling and comforting communication of the instability of cultural values
and identities that puts ethical, social and political codes into play.
|