Title:
|
A study of alternative frameworks in school science
|
This study makes use of a constructivist epistemological
stance (in particular that of George Kelly) to explore the . many conceptions young people develop for four concepts in
school science - energy, force, heat and light. The work is
placed within a growing area of research into students' alternative
conceptual frameworks and by adopting a broad, actionable,
notion of a concept it is possible to explore the
beliefs and contingencies that pervade these youngsters'
personal theories. The central methodology involved is an
individual interview approach framed around a set of line
drawings depicting various situations which the students are
asked to discuss in terms of their own conceptions. The
interview sessions are conducted in schoo~and are audiorecorded.
The four concepts are treated separately across
three age bands and the resulting four-by-three, twelve cell,
matrix lays the pattern for the analysis and d~scussion of
data. Three levels of analysis are discussed which are
conceptions, categories of response and frameworks, and these
are used as a means of examining the transcript data for some
134 interviews. The relatic1nships betwaen the frameworks are
considered and some emphasis is given to the degree of overlap
that occurs in the students' use of the four main concepts.
The responses of four particular students are explored across
all four concepts and the resulting four-by-four, sixteen
cell, matrix allows a study of their personalised approach
to these ideas in further detail. The methodological checks
employed are evaluated and, finally, summaries of the outcomesof the study are made, implications for current practices in
science education are drawn and future trends for research
are indicated.
|