Title:
|
Domesticating modernity : undertsanding women's aspirations in participatory literacy programmes in Uganda
|
Adult education programmes in East Africa have historically combined literacy training
with a range of efforts to shape the way African women expressed their femininity and
sexuality. Early missionaries believed that literacy together with Victorian ideals of
feminine propriety, housewifery and mothering would engender 'civilisation' in African
women. Today, assisting women to undergo a process of self-realisation is more likely
an aim of literacy programmes and reported impacts are more readily attributed to the
use of participatory methods than to literacy learning. My first aim is to show that
participatory approaches to adult learning are vulnerable to prescriptive manipUlations
in the way conventional literacy programmes have long been.
This ethnographic study focuses on two NGO literacy programmes in Uganda, one
urban, one rural; to explore how women learners construct knowledge during the
learning process; how they and others around them perceive this effort and its outcomes,
and how this tallies with the expectations development practitioners invest in adult
education. Women's ambitions are analysed both with regard to those themes of study
that have been popular since colonial times (i.e. health and hygiene) and with regard to
more recent concerns for women's empowerment (gender equality in the domestic and
public domain). Regardless of their own intentions, programme makers are found to
exercise only limited influence over the outcomes of literacy programmes. My second
objective is then to illustrate how women learners and facilitators selectively interpret
and internalise learning themes and use the messages received or construed to advance
their own position in their social contexts. To this end women may prize externally
visible health and hygiene practices as symbols of their own conversion to modem ways
of living, showing less interest in benefits to physical well-being that may ensue. The
desire to be recognised as a 'proper' woman also takes priority over attempts to overtly
challenge prevailing norms of gender relations, not because of women's conservatism,
but on the contrary, because gender relations already are subject to much overt and
covert tension outside of the classes. In conclusion, the aspirations women develop from
within their cultural context are seen to mould literacy programmes and their outcomes
more significantly than the degree to which participatory methods are followed.
|