Title:
|
Do age and teaching method affect children's cognitive abilities? : a follow-up
|
There is growing evidence for the efficacy of cognitive behaviour therapy (CBT) for
the treatment of mental disorders in adults, but its efficacy with children has been
queried due to the common assertion that children do not possess the cognitive
abilities needed to engage in CBT. However, some argue that CBT must be adapted
for children within a developmental framework.
A study conducted by Doherr (2000) provided positive findings suggesting that
children aged 5-8 years do possess cognitive abilities needed for CBT. The results also
indicated that children who attended a school with innovative teaching methods
demonstrated a greater degree of ability. Doherr (2000) proposed that such teaching
methods might enhance children's cognitive abilities.
The current research examined whether the findings from Doherr's (2000) study could
be replicated in a sample of 75 children (aged 8-10 years) from two Middle Schools.
The children were divided into three groups for the purpose of the present study: (1)
previously received innovative teaching; (2) previously received conventional
teaching and in class with children who have previously received innovative teaching;
and (3) previously received conventional teaching and not in class with children who
have previously received innovative teaching. Degree of ability was examined using a
cognitive behaviour therapy ability (CBTA) measure (Doherr, 2000). The results
indicated that those who had received innovative teaching did not maintain theenhanced ability. In addition, no significant difference of ability between ages was
found.
The findings were discussed with reference to their implications in terms of
theoretical, clinical and educational issues. One of the main issues discussed is
whether the continuation of the innovative teaching methods would maintain enhanced
ability and thus perhaps serve as a protective factor in the development of childhood
psychological disorders. Some further research ideas are proposed
|