Use this URL to cite or link to this record in EThOS:
Title: The right of the child to religious freedom in international law
Author: Langlaude, Sylvie.
ISNI:       0000 0000 4124 1610
Awarding Body: University of Bristol
Current Institution: University of Bristol
Date of Award: 2006
Availability of Full Text:
Access through EThOS:
Background and justification: Yemen is a high-fertility country with elevated levels of maternal mortality and unmet need for family planning. The government of Yemen conceived family planning services as an integrated part of the overall reproductive health services. Yet despite these compelling reasons for family planning services, and despite the unmet need, the services that do exist are often under-utilized. One hypothesis explaining this conflict between need and practice is the poor quality of the services that are offered. Despite the growing body of literature aimed at defining and measuring quality of care in family planning in recent years, the literature review reveals a number of gaps and unanswered questions. Among these are the concerns that the dimensions of quality may be perceived and defined differently by clients than by the researcher, the need of approach of greater depth that explores the full range of manifested and latent dimensions of client provider interactions, their determinants and their consequences and the question of underutilization. Moreover, the voice and view of clients that are essential aspects in initiatives to improve the quality of care provided by family planning programmes are often neglected. A comprehensive acceptable approach for assessing the quality of family planning services will help in effecting change to improve services delivery and to ensure that limited and declining resources which are available for health services are utilized in the most effective and efficient way. Aims and specific objectives: The study was conducted to develop a systematic approach for assessment of the quality of family planning services that is appropriate for Yemen and perhaps for other Middle Eastern countries. This approach will provide policy and decision makers in Yemen with appropriate information to improve the quality and utilisation of the services. The study has five specific objectives: 1. To measure the quality of family planning services provided by service delivery points (governmental and non-governmental organizations) in Sana'a city, according to the following six elements of quality in the Bruce-framework: i) Choice of methods. ii) Information given to clients. iii) Technical competence. iv) Interpersonal relations. v) Follow-up and continuity mechanisms. vi) Appropriate constellation of services. 2.To identify whether there are variations in the levels of quality of care related to the type of service delivery points (governmental and non - governmental organizations ).3. To study the perception of clients for the quality of care of family planning services. 4. To further develop the Bruce-framework for the assessment of quality of care of family planning services. 5.To measure utilization of services, in relation to the type of service delivery points (governmental and non-governmental organizations). Methods: The study is a descriptive and cross sectional .It includes all service delivery points (clinics) providing family planning services within the Government and non-governmental organizations in Sana'a city. The target populations were clients attending the service delivery points seeking family planning services during the period of the study. Data collection instrument consisted of: in-depth interviews with family planning clients, exit interviews with clients, direct observation of clientprovider interaction and review and analysis of service statistic data. The exit interview data collection instrument was designed to help in recording what happens when a provider counsels and examines a family planning client. The observation of client-provider interactions provided most of the information regarding how a client is counseled, examined, and provided with a method. From the client perspective the assessment of quality of care is a complex subject, and concurrent use of additional data collection method is required to ensure validity. In this respect, in-depth interviews were used concurrently with a quantitative study. The aim of in-depth interviewing was to elicit the interviewee's perspective, rather than that imposed upon by the researcher. Service statistic data were collected to measure the utilization of services. Data was validated and entered using the SPSS statistical package. The analysis includes summary statistics, frequency distribution, cross-tabulation, and measures of associations based on the chi-square test of independence. Multivariate analysis using logistic regression was applied to the data on client's personal characteristics. For analysis of the in-depth interview we used content analysis. Results: Assessment ofthe interpersonal element of quality of care raises a concern with privacy, as clients needs for privacy is, for most of the time, not considered in both sectors, although the NGOs give relatively more attention to this aspect. Clients are not given a chance to express their concerns or to ask questions and most of the time they are not told in advance about the medical examination they should undergo. This applies to both sectors, governmental and non-governmental. For the choice of method aspect of quality the data revealed that both sectors are performing well in terms of providing clients their preferred method of family planning. Although there is low information given about condom, in fact condom was also found to be the least preferred method by clients. Information given to clients is an extremely weak programme element in both sectors, both in terms of family planning information and even more so in terms of STD/HIV. The findings on the quality of pelvic examination and IUD insertion are not encouraging for both sectors. The main concern found was aseptic procedures, particularly in the use of gloves during pelvic examinations. STD screening at least through introductory questions on possible symptoms is not carried out consistently. The NGO providers seem to do better at infonning their clients of the date for their next visit compared to their government counterparts. However, not many clients are told that they can switch method if they were not satisfied with their current method, especially within the government setting. Clients approaching NGOs complained of long waiting hours, which was not the case for their government counterparts. For most of the clients who responded to the indepth interview, quality means the way of treatment they encounter. Clients perceive that good treatment involves staff attitudes, and they also identified staff technical competence and communication skills as prerequisite for good treatment. Themes emerging from the analysis of the in-depth interview transcript includes, good treatment, privacy during examination and consultation, good medical attention, effect of contraceptive on client health, social and cultural barriers (provider bias, obedience to husband and covert use of contraceptive), gender role (gender disparities and power imbalance between clients and their spouses). In general clients tend to focus upon the processes of services of care, as well as to the outcome of the services, rather than organizational structure or policy. Clients also focus on the socio-cultural barriers, which hinder their access to quality services and to comply with provider's recommendations. The three vantage points from which clients view quality are; the social and cultural barriers, the service -given process itself and the outcome of care, particularly with respect to individual knowledge and satisfaction with services. Conclusion and Recommendation: The substantive results from the study suggest that the quality of care being provided could be improved. The overall weakness of the programme revolves mainly around family planning counseling, asepsis and STD/HIV integration. The most important aspect however lies in the poor interpersonal relations aspect of care, as client needs for privacy are not being taken into consideration as well as their social context. Without a through understanding of women's perceptions of family planning in specific contexts, we run the risk of incorrectly homogenizing and universalizing women and their needs, which would waken the effectiveness of family planning programmes. Quality is a broad concept that no single approach adequately and fully measures. Alone any single approach can address only a piece of the total quality picture. Improving quality of care for clients means understanding their cultural values, previous experiences, and perceptions of the role of the health system, and then bringing service providers and the client's representative together to map out a shared vision of quality.
Supervisor: Not available Sponsor: Not available
Qualification Name: Thesis (Ph.D.) Qualification Level: Doctoral
EThOS ID:  DOI: Not available